Sheltered teal water beside a private dock, palm-lined lawn and a low white waterfront house in coastal South Florida.

Who Is Buying Surfside's Waterfront Houses on Bay Drive and 88th Street

On Aug. 27, 2026, a waterfront house at 9250 Bay Drive sold for $12.5 million to an LLC linked to developer Jacob Ohayon. The Real Deal described the house as about 2,600 square feet and reported that it last sold for $9.4 million in 2022. The purchase was financed with a $9,062,500 bridge loan from Winston Capital, and the land under the house is 17,550 square feet. The seller, Sontag Group CEO Samuel Sontag, had paid $8 million for land at 700 88th Street in June.

A developer bought a small older house on a big lot, using a loan built for a short hold, and the seller had already moved on to more land a few blocks away. Trades like these now shape prices along this short stretch of Surfside water. A builder pays for the lot and the frontage, and the house standing there today counts for little in the number.

The Water These Lots Face

According to the Town of Surfside's 2018 Comprehensive Plan, Point Lake is the dredged channel that separates Biscaya Island from the rest of town, and the plan counts it as part of Biscayne Bay. The western end of Bay Drive meets the Point Lake bulkhead, and the western ends of 90th Street and 92nd through 95th Streets reach Indian Creek. Biscaya Island connects to the rest of Surfside by the short Biscaya Bridge on 88th Street.

That leaves Surfside with a small supply of lots on open bay water, and in 2026 most of the town's large house trades and construction loans have been on Bay Drive and on 88th Street near that bridge.

The 2026 Ledger

Address Date Transaction Amount
9224 Bay Drive Feb. 17, 2026 Sale, 4,678 sq. ft. house $13.875 million
8900 Bay Drive April 2026 Sale, waterfront house $14.3 million
700 88th Street June 5, 2026 Land sale $8 million
608 88th Street Aug. 25, 2026 Bridge loan for a planned spec house $17.5 million
9250 Bay Drive Aug. 27, 2026 Sale, about 2,600 sq. ft. house $12.5 million

The per-foot figures on these sales swing widely. On Feb. 17, 2026, 9224 Bay Drive, a 4,678-square-foot house, sold for $13.875 million, roughly $2,966 per square foot. The August 2026 sale of 9250 Bay Drive comes to well over $4,000 per square foot of house, on a house about half that size. Measured against the 17,550-square-foot lot, the same $12.5 million works out to about $712 per square foot of land. Of these measures, the land figure fits the buyer best, because the buyer is a developer.

8900 Bay Drive sold for $14.3 million, and The Real Deal reported that the house was then offered for rent at $35,000 a month. So a finished house on this water also has rental value while its owner decides what to do next.

A trade off the water shows the gap. On June 14, 2026, 500 94th Street, a 3,320-square-foot house, sold for $5.15 million, or about $1,551 per square foot. That is a strong price for Surfside, and it is less than two-thirds of the $8 million paid for the bare land at 700 88th Street that same month.

The Ceiling Came From a Spec House

Surfside's house price record has risen by steps over the past three years, and the biggest step came from a builder. In 2023, 1236 Biscaya Drive on Biscaya Island set the town record at $15.3 million. In September 2024, The Real Deal reported that spec developers Reuven and Iris Herssein had sold 9208 Bay Drive for $19.8 million. The house is 9,600 square feet, was finished in 2023, and had been listed at $22.5 million. Reuven Herssein told the outlet that his wife found the lot and designed the home, and that he built it.

The record price works out to about $2,063 per square foot of house, which is below the per-foot figure on several smaller 2026 sales on the same street. Buyers paid more in total for the larger new house and less per foot of it. They are paying mostly for the lot and the water, and a builder who adds 9,600 finished square feet to the lot can push the total higher.

The next projects aim above that record. Kort Development planned two Kobi Karp-designed waterfront homes, at 9540 Bay Drive and at 600 88th Street. They were financed with a $25 million construction loan from Vaster that closed in March 2025. The financing record shows about 13,797 square feet with 125 feet of water frontage at 9540 Bay Drive, and 9,919 square feet with 75 feet of frontage at 600 88th Street. In May 2025, The Real Deal reported that the Bay Drive home could list for more than $25 million.

An 18-Month Clock on 88th Street

At 608 88th Street, a $17.5 million bridge loan from Winston Capital closed on Aug. 25, 2026. The loan has an 18-month term and is for a planned 9,000-square-foot spec house. The lot is 15,075 square feet on the water, and the building on it now is 4,551 square feet. Kort's 600 88th Street project is next door, and the $8 million land sale at 700 88th Street is one block over.

An 18-month loan puts a builder on a schedule, with design, approvals and construction all inside that window. On Bay Drive, the same schedule shows up in the price. The 9250 Bay Drive lot sold in August 2026 for $3.1 million more than its 2022 price, and the buyer was a developer.

Lenders have backed this kind of building across the region. In 2025, Celestial Fund CEO Eugene Rutenberg told The Real Deal that "there's no way to replace having your own pad, your own space, your own personal guard," and singled out South American buyers. The same report said that, according to lenders, buyers want turnkey homes. Spec builder Curnin told the outlet that for well-built homes above $20 million to $25 million in good locations, "the demand is very strong." He also said land for the product he wants to build is "almost non-existent." Surfside's Point Lake frontage is one of the few places where that land still trades, a lot at a time.

What It Means at the Offer Table

Anyone shopping for an older waterfront house to live in on Bay Drive or 88th Street is likely bidding against a builder working out what the lot is worth once a new house is on it. The two 2026 sales nearest $14 million, 9224 and 8900 Bay Drive, show where existing houses have been trading. The $12.5 million paid for 9250 Bay Drive shows what a builder paid for a lot whose house was a smaller part of the deal. An offer on this frontage gets a fairer comparison from the lot size, the feet of water frontage and recent land trades nearby than from interior square footage. The same reasoning holds just across the water on West Island, which we covered in Bay Harbor Islands' new land record.

The spec projects on 88th Street and Bay Drive mean that newly built houses will reach this stretch of Point Lake over the next few years, each priced against the $19.8 million record at 9208 Bay Drive and Kort's reported goal of more than $25 million. A buyer who would rather wait for a finished house should expect that price level, well above where the older houses are trading now.

Owners of older houses on this water face the same arithmetic from the other side, since builders are among their likely buyers and builder bids track the lot. A valuation for a Bay Drive or 88th Street waterfront house should be based on recent land and teardown trades such as 9250 Bay Drive and 700 88th Street, as well as on finished-house sales. A house's square footage, its condition, or a sale price per square foot elsewhere in town will not tell you much here.

Allen Davoudpour has lived in Surfside since 2014, and The Davoudpour Team works with buyers and sellers across Surfside's waterfront streets. If you are pricing a waterfront house on Bay Drive or 88th Street, or weighing an older house against a new build, schedule a consultation and we will go through the lot-level comparisons with you.

Work With Allen

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.

Follow Me on Instagram